Intelligent perception and interaction with the world hinges on internal representations that capture its underlying geometry ('disentangled' or 'abstract' representations). The ability to form these disentangled representations from high-dimensional, noisy observations is a hallmark of intelligence, observed in both biological and artificial systems. In this opinion paper we highlight unpublished experimental and theoretical results guaranteeing the emergence of disentangled representations in agents that optimally solve multi-task evidence aggregation classification tasks, canonical in the cognitive neuroscience literature. The key conceptual finding is that, by producing accurate multi-task classification estimates, a system implicitly represents a set of coordinates specifying a disentangled, topology-preserving representation of the underlying latent space. Since the theory relies only on the system accurately computing the classification probabilities, we are able to derive a closed-form solution for extracting disentangled representations from any multi-task classification system. The theory provides conditions for the emergence of these representations in terms of noise, number of tasks, and evidence aggregation time, and we experimentally validate the theoretical predictions on RNNs and GPT-2 style models solving such canonical evidence-aggregation decision-making neuroscience tasks. It turns out that GPT models are much better at disentangling factors, showcasing their unique ability in grokking world models. We here discuss implications of these findings, for machine learning and neuroscience alike.