Self-supervised learning (SSL) has been an important ingredient in developing strong monocular depth estimation models in recent years. However, despite these improvements, our study reveals that the later layers of the SOTA SSL method are actually suboptimal. By examining the layer-wise representations, we demonstrate significant changes in these later layers during fine-tuning, indicating the ineffectiveness of their pre-trained features for depth estimation. To address these limitations, we propose MeSa, a comprehensive framework that leverages the complementary strengths of masked, geometric, and supervised pre-training. Our CKA layer-wise analysis confirms that our pre-training strategy indeed produces improved representations for the later layers, overcoming the drawbacks of the SOTA SSL method. Furthermore, via experiments on the NYUv2 and IBims-1 datasets, we demonstrate that these enhanced representations translate to performance improvements in both the in-distribution and out-of-distribution settings. We also investigate the influence of the pre-training dataset and demonstrate the efficacy of pre-training on LSUN, which yields significantly better pre-trained representations. Overall, our approach surpasses the masked pre-training SSL method by a substantial margin of 17.1% on the RMSE. Moreover, even without utilizing any recently proposed techniques, MeSa also outperforms the most recent methods and establishes a new state-of-the-art for monocular depth estimation on the challenging NYUv2 dataset.